Juana de Pargament speaks boldly, passionately, and without stopping. This indomitable 90- year-old marches around the Plaza de Mayo in Buenos Aires at 3:30 PM every Thursday, arm-in-arm with other mothers.
Juana is a founder of the Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo, women who protested their children’s disappearances during Argentina’s brutal military dictatorship, the so-called “dirty war,” from 1976- 1983. She has been marching for 27 years
The Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo began the fight as a group of 14 on April 30, 1977. After former president Isabel Peron declared a state of siege. Under the “Doctrine of National Security,” fighting communism and upholding Christianity were trademarks of a regime based on censorship and persecution of sub- versives.
Dazed by a sudden surge in the kidnappings, which had begun as early as 1971, the Mothers banded together to demand information. When General Jorge Rafael Videla refused to meet with them, former President Azucena Villaflor suggested they assemble in the plaza facing the Casa Rosada—the presidential palace.
The middle-aged and older women, most of whom had never been politically active before, suddenly faced snarling dogs, police brutality, and death threats, which continue today.
According to Bonafini’s account in the History of the Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo, the women were condemned as mothers of “terrorists.” Several original Mothers, including Villaflor, disappeared. In 1979 they resorted to secret church meetings for fear of harshening repercussions. “Our children were militants, they knew about all this, but we didn’t. We were still working in our kitchens,” says Juana. “We went into the streets to look for them. We knocked on every door. Everything was, ‘No. We haven’t seen them, we don’t know them, we don’t recognize them.’”
The Mothers eventually discovered that their children were held in 340 secret detention centers where they were tortured, killed, and sometimes thrown into the ocean
Juana says lawyers, doctors, and psychologists participated in the systematic torture, with doctors determining how much prisoners could withstand each day without dying. The Mothers have also accused Pepsi, Coca-Cola, and the sugar refinery Ledesma of lending trucks for kidnappings.
Juana and the other Mothers agitated internationally, eventually provoking criticism of Argentina by journalists, human rights organizations, and the United Nations— earning a UNESCO Prize for Peace Education in 1999 and inspiring women’s groups from Holland to Guatemala. However, even as they were promised help, State Department officials maintained covert business relationships with the military. In fact, many military officials had been trained in U.S. military academies to fight the spread of “communism.”
“We believed they were listening with love and understanding. But it was not true,” Juana jabs the air for emphasis. “Carter tricked us, they all did.”
During Operation Condor—the code name for the secret regional South American plan to share intelligence on suspected Marxists—the Mothers received no support from the Chilean military government and activists were detained in Brazil and Uruguay as they tried to escape. The Mothers also received little aid from the Catholic Church, even though nuns and priests also disappeared. “Of the 80 bishops, only four understood us,” says Juana. “The rest supported the military, like the pope.” According to Juana, former papal envoy Pio Laghi entered concentration camps and signed death sentences. “He kicked the kids that were being tortured and said, ‘Tell them everything you know and you will be saved.’ And they still weren’t saved.”
Juana, who is Jewish, claims about 2,000 Jews were among the disappeared, with Jewish prisoners receiving “double the torture.” They were made to walk on all fours and paint their bodies with swastikas, as Nazi music blared. When the Mothers asked the Israeli embassy to save the Jewish disappeared, the Mothers were told Israel didn’t want them either because they were revolutionaries.
After the transfer to democracy in 1983, the Mothers met with new President Raúl Alfonsín, but found him unresponsive. He formed the National Commission on the Disappeared (CONADEP), which released explosive details of military repression, but found only 9,000 disappeared. The Mothers estimate at least 30,000
Even as they continue to agitate, the Mothers have also moved into a new role—teachers. Visitors often use them as a primary resource to understand a past Argentines are loath to discuss. The Mothers have written several histories, profiles of the disappeared, and a monthly newspaper. Their headquarters houses a revolutionary bookstore, cafe, and library. In 2000, they began the Popular University of the Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo, offering an activist education unavailable in mainstream schools.
Juana thinks young activists should immerse themselves in history, but steer clear of violent conflict. “Save the country with concepts, with feelings, with morality, not with the savagery of the military,” she says. “We fight so new leaders are born to govern with honesty and love. When we don’t live anymore, we want people to remember our example and what happened in this country that made us give our lives to change it once and for all.”
Amanda Schoenberg has worked as a reporter for The Tico Times, in San Jose, Costa Rica.
She spoke in a hushed tone. As if every word she uttered was of the greatest importance & meant only for me. I had gone to her house in distress. I had done the right thing. I had told the truth. Now I was being punished. It just wasn’t right. Aunt Gert tabbed my tears away with the end of her shawl & plunked me on the sofa next to her, in front of a blazing fire. She always had the sofa a little too close to the fire for my liking. After sitting my face almost immediately roasted. But cuddled into her side I felt safe so I didn’t want to complain, afraid she might move me to a seat away from her.
“The truth is not an easy thing,” she whispered. “Most of the time people try their damnedest to ignore it because they know it isn’t always sweet. It can make us ache & bleed. It can cause secrets & pain to spill from our eyes, liquid & vulnerable.”
She hugged me a little closer & bend her head down to my ear. A strand of her silver hair tickled my nose & I brushed it way. ” You should never be afraid to speak the truth. But you’ll spend your life being nothing but a silly little girl if you expect it to be gentle. Truth does what it must, with no real regard for anyone in it’s path. So you must always speak the truth, then brace yourself & make damn sure to stay to it’s right side.”
I giggled, hearing Aunt Gert curse sounded funny but the serious look on her face cut me short. I quickly put on my church face & nodded in acknowledgement.
Laying there I started to think about what was true. It was true that I still didn’t quite understand why every one was angry with me. It was also true that Aunt Gert wasn’t upset with me at all. Actually, she was proud of me. And that made me feel better, a whole lot better. I curled up a little tighter & fell into a deep sleep, roasting in front of Aunt Gert’s fire.
She felt like she would drown in the silence that had seized the small space between them. Than, a spark of emotion, one she hadn’t felt in a while, a tiny memory of things lost drifted into her mind. There in front of her was the man she had once known. Who’s body she could recite as beloved poetry.
Gone! as quickly as it had come. She was slammed back into reality by a flash of sunlight bounced off of his single piece of jewellry, a thin gold wedding band. A knot filled her stomach, she lost her appetite & excused herself from the table. After splashing some cold water on her face she decided she couldn’t go back in, it was too embarrassing. She collected her coat & headed for the front door. She would explain things to Tina later, somehow. Outside the night air felt comforting. Suddenly there was a jerk on the elbow…literally. As she spun around to see David standing there, with his face contorted to look like what she guessed was a puppy dog.
“Talk to me, let me explain.”
“There’s really nothing to explain. There is no excuse & I don’t want an apology. So you see we’re really left with nothing.” She was surprised how the words felt falling from her mouth, how strong she felt.
She pulled her arm away from him & turned to hail a cab.
“You don’t understand,” He pleaded. “Jessica & I have a very open relationship. I’m not a lying cheat”
She turn in honest disbelief. “That’s your explaination?” Really? That’s all you got? Wow, and to think I was once attracted to that brain. What a foolish little girl I was.” She went to open the cab door when David forced it shut. “I miss us. And Jessica knows all about you.”
It all seemed so comical, she almost laughed out loud. “I’m so glad that your wife is OK with her husband sleeping with another woman. Unfortunately, I’m not OK with my boyfriend sleeping with anyone but me. I know, I’m kinda quirky that way.” She knew the sarcasm wasn’t necessary but it made her feel good. And right now that’s all that mattered. “I’m very glad you respect your wife enough to tell her the truth. Maybe someday one of your girlfriends will be worth the same courtesy.” David let go of the cab door & Johanna calmly seated herself inside.
Driving away, she thought for sure she’d burst into tears, but instead she started to laugh, so hard the cabbie turned to ask if she was alright. She was better than alright. Random chance had freed her from naked desire & made it possible for her to really see past the manipulations of the body, his body. She felt great. Maybe she’d celebrate.
RUT= ‘a fixed or established mode of procedure or course in life, usually dull or unpromising. ‘
And this is exactly where I find myself today. The last place I want to be, yet here I am. WORK-EAT-SLEEP.
The things we want take time to build. A lesson I have yet to truly absorb.
He had this smile that never seemed to fade. Like he knew something that no one else knew. A private joke & only he knew the punchline. Even when his mouth was straight & structured, not curled into that grin, his eyes shone & laughed out loud. It made me giggle in my tummy just to see him.
A calmness enveloped him. It radiated off his person & smelled fragrant, dewy lilacs in the spring. I never had to speak. Just sitting with him, feeling that feeling & smelling that smell made me feel joyful.
I think some people are just born that way. You see, some people learn wisdom. They study, pilgrimage & make calm a goal. Others never give it a second thought. Life is pain & work & rush hour. Fight, accumulate, die! But some very special people are just born a step ahead of the rest of us. As children, there’s a honey sweet restfulness about them. As toddlers they hold your gaze & their eyes dance. Because they know something you don’t know…& it’s funny. Beautiful funny.
They can’t & don’t try to explain it. There are no words. It’s breath or gravity, it just is.
My grandmother insisted that people like this had old souls. They’d been around the block a time or two. And if it seemed like they knew more about life, love & the human condition then you did, it was because they did. The older a soul, the closer it is to God & to Truth.
I often wondered what Truth he had locked away in those eyes? If I asked would he tell me? Could I have calm & smell like Spring?




